How to Evaluate a Medicare Plan Based on Your Prescription Drug Needs

How to Evaluate a Medicare Plan Based on Your Prescription Drug Needs

May 26, 20256 min read

Are you trying to find the right Medicare plan that covers all your medications without breaking the bank? At Bourgeois Insurance Agency, LLC in Thibodaux, Louisiana, we understand that navigating Medicare prescription drug coverage can feel overwhelming. But don't worry – we're here to help you understand how to choose the best Medicare plan for your specific prescription needs.

Understanding Medicare Prescription Drug Coverage Options

When it comes to getting Medicare prescription drug coverage, you have two main options:

  1. Medicare Part D prescription drug plans that add drug coverage to Original Medicare

  2. Medicare Advantage plans that include prescription drug coverage

But how do you know which plan is right for you? Let's break it down so you can make an informed decision about your healthcare.

How to Review a Medicare Plan's Drug List (Formulary)

Every Medicare prescription drug plan has a formulary – a list of prescription drugs the plan covers. This list is incredibly important because if your medications aren't on it, you'll likely pay much more out-of-pocket.

Here's what to look for when checking a plan's formulary:

  • Are all your current medications included?

  • Which tier (pricing level) are your drugs placed in?

  • Does the plan cover the type of drugs you might need in the future?

Medicare Part D plans must include at least two drugs in most categories and must cover all medications in six protected classes, including antidepressants and cancer drugs. But beyond these requirements, drug lists can vary widely between plans.

Have you checked if your medications are covered under your current plan? If not, now might be a good time to review!

Understanding Drug Costs in Medicare Part D Plans

The cost of prescription drugs under Medicare isn't just about the monthly premium. When evaluating drug plans, consider:

  1. Monthly premiums – what you pay each month for coverage

  2. Annual deductible – what you pay before your plan starts to pay

  3. Copayments/coinsurance – your share of the cost for each prescription

  4. Coverage gap (donut hole) – a temporary limit on what the plan will cover

  5. Catastrophic coverage – reduced costs after you've spent a certain amount

Remember that the cheapest premium doesn't always mean the lowest overall drug costs. A plan with a higher premium might actually save you money if it covers your specific medications at lower copays.

How to Use the Medicare Plan Finder to Compare Drug Plans

Medicare offers a helpful tool called the Plan Finder that allows you to compare Medicare drug plans based on your specific medications. Here's how to use it effectively:

  1. Gather a list of all your prescription drugs, including dosages and how often you take them

  2. Visit the Medicare website and use the Plan Finder tool

  3. Enter your medications to see which plans cover them and at what cost

  4. Compare the total annual cost, not just the monthly premium

This tool helps you find the best Medicare Part D prescription drug coverage for your needs by showing you exactly what you'll pay throughout the year.

Important Factors That Affect Prescription Drug Coverage

When choosing the right Medicare plan for your prescription needs, don't overlook these important factors:

Pharmacy Networks and Preferred Pharmacies

Many Medicare drug plans have preferred pharmacies where you'll pay less for the same medications. Check if your local pharmacy is in the plan's network, or if you'd need to switch to save money.

At Bourgeois Insurance Agency, LLC, we can help you find plans that work with your preferred local pharmacies in Thibodaux and surrounding areas.

Utilization Management Tools

Some plans use tools to manage how you use certain drugs:

  • Prior authorization – your doctor must show the drug is medically necessary

  • Quantity limits – restrictions on how much medication you can get at once

  • Step therapy – trying less expensive drugs before "stepping up" to more expensive ones

These rules can affect how easily you can get your medications, so they're important to consider when selecting a plan.

When Can You Enroll or Switch Medicare Part D Plans?

Understanding enrollment periods is crucial when selecting Medicare prescription drug coverage:

  • Initial Enrollment Period – when you first become eligible for Medicare

  • Annual Open Enrollment Period (October 15–December 7) – when you can join, switch, or drop a plan

  • Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1–March 31) – when you can switch Medicare Advantage plans or return to Original Medicare and join a drug plan

  • Special Enrollment Periods – based on certain life events or circumstances

Missing these enrollment periods could mean waiting for coverage or paying penalties, so timing matters!

How to Get Help Choosing the Right Medicare Plan

Choosing the right Medicare plan for your prescription drug needs doesn't have to be a solo journey. There are several resources available:

  • Contact Bourgeois Insurance Agency, LLC at (985) 803-8999 for personalized assistance

  • The State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) offers free Medicare counseling

  • The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services provides resources and support

Important Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Medicare Drug Plan

As you evaluate your options, ask yourself:

  1. Does this plan cover all my prescription drugs?

  2. What will my total costs be (premium, deductible, copays)?

  3. Can I use my preferred pharmacies?

  4. Are there any restrictions on my medications?

  5. How is the plan rated for customer service and satisfaction?

Making the Switch: How to Change Medicare Part D Plans

If you find that your current plan doesn't meet your needs, you can switch Medicare Part D plans during the Annual Open Enrollment Period. Here's how:

  1. Research and select a new plan that better covers your medications

  2. Enroll in the new plan (you'll automatically be disenrolled from your old plan)

  3. Make sure you have enough medication to last through the transition

  4. Update your pharmacy with your new insurance information

Have your medication needs changed recently? It might be time to review your coverage options!

Why Local Expertise Matters When Choosing Medicare Drug Coverage

National Medicare information is helpful, but local expertise can make a real difference. At Bourgeois Insurance Agency, LLC in Thibodaux, Louisiana, we understand the specific plan options available in our area and which ones work best with local pharmacies and healthcare providers.

We've helped many of your neighbors find the right Medicare prescription drug coverage, and we'd love to help you too. Give us a call at (985) 803-8999 to discuss your specific needs.

Take Action: Get Medicare Prescription Drug Coverage That Works for You

Don't let confusion about Medicare prescription drug benefits keep you from getting the coverage you need. Taking these steps can help ensure you get the right plan:

  1. Make a complete list of your prescription drugs

  2. Compare plans using the Medicare Plan Finder

  3. Consider all costs, not just premiums

  4. Check if your pharmacy is preferred

  5. Review plan ratings and satisfaction scores

  6. Get expert help from Bourgeois Insurance Agency, LLC

Remember, the best plan for your friend or neighbor might not be the best one for you – your medication needs are unique!

Would you like personalized guidance on finding the perfect Medicare prescription drug plan for your specific needs? Contact Bourgeois Insurance Agency, LLC today at (985) 803-8999. We're proud to serve the Thibodaux community with caring, expert advice that puts your health first.

Price Started in the insurance industry over 20 years ago. Working for several well known large corporations over the years but found he could serve his clients and community better as an Independent Agency offering Medicare Supplements (Medigap), Medicare Advantage Plans, Prescription Drug Plans (PDP), and Retirement Planning Services.

Price has spent years building one of the top agencies in the Thibodaux, Louisiana. Dedicated to finding the best solutions and staying up to date on insurance trends and products.

Price Bourgeois

Price Started in the insurance industry over 20 years ago. Working for several well known large corporations over the years but found he could serve his clients and community better as an Independent Agency offering Medicare Supplements (Medigap), Medicare Advantage Plans, Prescription Drug Plans (PDP), and Retirement Planning Services. Price has spent years building one of the top agencies in the Thibodaux, Louisiana. Dedicated to finding the best solutions and staying up to date on insurance trends and products.

LinkedIn logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog